In October 2026, Paris experienced a succession of events that brutally illustrate the thesis that public space is never a neutral place, but rather the stage on which the question of who has the right to use violence, and in whose name, is played out. Between the riots of 17 October, the clashes of 24 October, the racist terrorist attack in Trappes and La Verrière on 23 October, and the prospect of further mobilisations on 31 October, the French capital provides material for questioning European Christianity, non-violence, and the legitimacy of coercion. These three episodes – social unrest, a racist attack, and confrontation with the police – do not stem from the same logic, but they raise the same question: at what point does violence cease to be condemnable and become, in the eyes of some, "legitimate”?
The violence of 17 October first raises the question of violence as a response to social injustice. Demonstrators were protesting against the high cost of living and conditions in schools; some of them resorted to looting and arson. Some will see this as "legitimate anger” that found a violent means of expression; others, as pure criminality that discredits the cause being defended. Christian thought offers two contradictory answers here. On the one hand, the Augustinian tradition of "just war” can, by analogy, tolerate a certain degree of collective violence when peaceful means have been exhausted and injustice is severe. On the other hand, radical non-violence, inherited from the Sermon on the Mount, categorically rejects any justification of violence, even in the face of oppression. René Girard offers a third, more unsettling interpretation: collective violence, even when presented as a revolt against injustice, reproduces the mechanism of the scapegoat. Looting, arson attacks on businesses, and attacks against the police: all these acts designate a symbolic culprit and temporarily restore an illusion of cohesion among the protesters. From this perspective, the violence of 17 October is not merely a response to the high cost of living. It is also a reactivation of the violent sacred that Christianity claims to transcend.
The attacks in Trappes and La Verrière illustrate another, more sinister facet of the problem. The suspect, Kevin T., acknowledged that he had targeted people because of their religion or perceived origin, while denying the racist nature of his actions, which he considered "legitimate”. This claim to legitimacy lies at the heart of the issue: those who commit acts of racial violence generally do not see themselves as criminals, but as vigilantes, defenders of a threatened order. This is where Girard's critique finds its full force. Designating a scapegoat makes it possible to channel diffuse social anxiety towards a concrete target and to restore, through violence, a sense of cohesion between the aggressor and those who support him. Christianity, in its most radical form, denounces precisely this mechanism: the Passion of Christ reveals the innocence of the victim and condemns any logic of collective sacrifice. The history of Christianity shows that this message can be reversed. Religious persecutions, the Crusades, colonisation: all these are examples in which Christians designated scapegoats in the name of faith. The attack in Trappes, although committed by an individual whose precise motives remain to be legally established, is part of a broader logic of the sacralisation of hatred, which Christianity, like every religion, must constantly combat within itself.
Confronted with this violence, the state responds with force: 70,000 police officers deployed, movement restrictions in certain neighbourhoods, tear gas, water cannons, helicopters flying over Place de la République. This response reiterates the classic question in political philosophy: does the state have a legitimate monopoly on violence, and to what extent can this monopoly be exercised without itself becoming a source of violence? The Christian tradition of non-violence offers an alternative here: what if the most effective response to violence were not more violence, but less? Martin Luther King, in the face of segregation, demonstrated that non-violence can be more powerful than repression. Applied to France in October 2026, this lesson suggests that the massive deployment of law enforcement forces, although necessary to protect people and property, is not sufficient to resolve the deep-rooted causes of anger – the high cost of living, inequality, and the feeling of abandonment. What makes Christianity particularly relevant to understanding these events is precisely its historical ambivalence. It carries within itself both the most radical demand for non-violence – "love your enemies” – and the memory of violence committed in its name. This dual legacy makes it an ideal mirror for a society which, like France in October 2026, oscillates between the desire to suppress violence and the need to understand its roots. The violence of 17 October, the racist attack of the 23rd, the clashes of the 24th: three faces of the same crisis, that of a society that no longer knows how to regulate its conflicts other than through force. Christianity, in its critical dimension, reminds us that all violence, even when apparently legitimate, reproduces the mechanism of the scapegoat and delays genuine reconciliation. Yet Christianity, in its historical dimension, also reminds us that no tradition, however noble, is immune to violent co-option. Centuries of religious wars, persecutions, and colonisation bear witness to this.
The violence in Paris in October 2026 is not a temporary anomaly, but a symptom of a profound impasse: that of a society that no longer knows how to distinguish legitimate violence from condemnable violence, or that claims to do so while multiplying forms of coercion. Between social unrest, racist hatred, and the state's massive response, public space in Paris becomes the laboratory of a question that Christianity, despite its contradictions, has never ceased to raise: how can one love one's enemy in a world that designates them as a scapegoat? The answer is neither simple nor consensual. But it may begin with recognition: violence, in all its forms – social, racist, state-sanctioned – is always a sign of failure, a failure of dialogue, justice, and mutual recognition. As long as this failure persists, public space will remain what it became in October 2026: a battlefield where the question of the legitimacy of violence is played out, week after week, in the streets.

Lasă un comentariu